Beach Plum Resort in Montauk offers polished studios with ocean views, a pool, BBQs, and is steps from the Atlantic Ocean and local attractions.
Guests appreciate the peaceful location near the beach and town, along with clean, well-equipped rooms and friendly, helpful staff. The resort offers relaxed accommodations with great ocean views and a welcoming atmosphere for a variety of travelers.
GoHotelly doesn't process bookings — we open this property on each partner so you can compare live rates, cancellation rules and loyalty perks side by side.
Some links are affiliate — if you book, GoHotelly may earn a small commission at no extra cost to you. Read the full disclosure.
Rooms, shared spaces, dining and exterior — grouped so you can skim quickly.
Beach Plum Resort offers polished studios and apartments with ocean views in a relaxed, clapboard-style setting. The property features an outdoor pool and BBQ areas, creating a casual atmosphere suitable for both short stays and extended visits. Located at 779 Old Montauk Hwy in Montauk, it combines easy access to nearby attractions with laid-back coastal charm.
Guests appreciate the resort's location, just a six-minute walk from the Atlantic Ocean and a short stroll to the Montauk Indian Museum. While it is close enough to Montauk village for dining, shopping, and entertainment, the resort remains quiet at night, providing a comfortable balance between convenience and tranquility. Montauk Downs State Park, offering sports and golf, lies about three miles away.
The Beach Plum Resort is known for its friendly and accommodating staff, with particular praise for attentive management and helpful services, contributing to a smooth guest experience. Rooms are noted to be clean and well maintained, although individual decor and features can vary since each unit is privately owned.
Suitable for a variety of guests including families, couples, and LGBTQ+ visitors, the resort embraces inclusivity and offers a welcoming environment. Nearby attractions include Montauk Point Lighthouse Museum, Hither Hills State Park, and Camp Hero State Park, providing opportunities for sightseeing, hiking, and outdoor activities. Accessibility to airports varies, with Long Island MacArthur Airport being the closest by car.
The short version: what's available day-to-day, and the key practical details most travelers search for.
Reviews from travelers who stayed here in the last 12 months, grouped to help you spot the pattern quickly.
We've been staying at the Beach Plum for 15 years. The proximity to the village is perfect for a walk to dinner or shopping, yet far enough to be quiet at night. The rooms we've stayed in over the years have always been clean and well maintained. The office and housekeeping staff are always friendly and helpful.
We have been coming here same week for 15+ years, the last several staying in Room 14. It’s equipped with a small refrigerator, electric cooktop (no oven), microwave. The room is clean, comfortable with an awesome view of the Atlantic. Best part of this resort is the management company, which has an on site office. Viviana and Barbara are awesome managers, friendly, always accommodating ! Online concierge service is great! Can’t wait to come back!
Had a great stay at Beach Plum for a long holiday weekend. The location is perfect - far enough away from town to avoid some of the crowds, but close enough where it's only a short 10 min walk. The beach across the street is where we spent most of our time, it was beautiful. Lastly, the views of the ocean from the balcony was the absolute best way to begin our days with a cup of coffee in hand. P.s. Barbara at the front desk helped us check in & check out, and assisted with any requests along the way. She was amazing!
The Beach Plum is a magnificent luxury hotel with beautiful accommodations not to mention the stunning views. We have been staying at Beach plum for over 12 years with our 4 children, and each year is as special as the next. The staff are exceptional, cratering to all details within each unit. They are helpful to all parties, whether you are a family of 6 like us, a bachelorette party or just two love birds getting away for the weekend. The Beach Plum resort is highly recommended.
I have been a regular guest at the Beach plum for over 15 years and have always had a positive experience. In all honesty, some of the rooms are nicer than others as they are each individually owned and decorated according to the owners taste. However, ALL the rooms are very clean and comfortable with private balcony's. The location is great. Walking/biking distance to town, shops, restaurants, entertainment etc.. and the beautiful beach is right across the street down a lovely path. The refreshing pool is always an option as well. Special mention should be made to Viviana and the entire staff, front desk, housekeeping etc... for their ongoing professionalism and going out of their way to make sure guests are happy and satisfied.
This is one of our favorite places to celebrate our mom's weekends. It's close to town yet far enough away to feel like we're not near town at all. We'll definitely be back.
The Beach Plum is such a hidden gem! It’s a quick drive or walk into town and the beach access is beautiful and quiet. The rooms have everything you need, and the staff are incredible, friendly, and accommodating. We love this place and will keep coming back to it.
Our family has been coming here for many many years - the location is PERFECT - beach right across the street - heated pool - a few minutes walk into town. The rooms are fabulous - all well stocked and well kept - we love staying on the top floor so we can enjoy that gorgeous ocean view. The staff - Viviana in particular - are the best - accomodating, friendly - just exemplary. We plan to continue to go to Beach Plum for many many years to come!! it is a real treasure.
A 6-minute walk from the Atlantic Ocean, this relaxed clapboard hotel off Highway 27 is a 5-minute walk from the Montauk Indian Museum, and 3 miles from dining, sports and golf facilities at Montauk Downs State Park.
Curated spots travelers usually pair with a stay in New York. Distances are rough real-world times, not straight-line.
6,047 reviews 2000 Montauk Hwy, Montauk, NY 11954, United States
272 reviews 1898 Montauk Hwy, Montauk, NY 11954, United States
835 reviews 164 Old Montauk Hwy, Montauk, NY 11954, United States
Hand-picked alternatives with a comparable feel, size and price band.
Lambertville House offers unique 19thcentury decor, marble baths, free WiFi, and a colonialstyle bar. Located near Downtown Lamb...
Stay at The Edgefield Inn in Edgefield, SC. Enjoy petfriendly rooms, free WiFi, continental breakfast, near Sumter National Fores...
Casual hotel with free breakfast, outdoor pool, and fitness center. Rated 3.9/5 with 558 reviews, near Acadian Village and downtow...
Stay at Sweetwater Branch Inn, a 4.8rated Victorian B&B in Gainesville with gardens, outdoor pool, wine receptions, near Universi...
Enjoy rustic cabins and simple rooms with waterfront access, boat rentals, and a lakeside pool at Bridgeport Resort in Cape Fair, ...
Enjoy rustic cabins with creek views at Cabin Creek Inn, Thayne, WY. Free breakfast, outdoor pool, and kidfriendly rooms near Hig...
Stay at Travelodge by Wyndham Charles Town/Harpers Ferry offering free WiFi, parking, and petfriendly rooms near Harpers Ferry N...
4.5star familyowned motel in Sedona offering basic rooms, free WiFi, patio with sunset views, LGBTQ+ friendly, near downtown an...
Stay at Pacer Inn & Suites Motel in Delaware, OH. Rated 4.4 with breakfast, restaurant, LGBTQ+ friendly, near Ohio Wesleyan Univer...
Clearwater Lakeshore Motel offers free breakfast, indoor pool, and private lakefront near Mackinaw City's top attractions. Rated 4...
Short, honest notes are more useful than long ones. A few sentences about what worked, what surprised you, and who the hotel is best for will go a long way.
